After reading the first four chapters of Burke and Hare, readers gain a better understanding of the underlying personalities of these main characters.  These men are compelled by money, and Dr. Knox, to commit murder in reward for monetary gain.  Dr. Knox is the scientist provoking Burke and Hare to commit these disgusting acts, and because of this I believe Dr. Knox is the "madman."  He is the man in charge of their relationship and is responsible for their motive behind killing.  Burke and Hare did not perform these acts maliciously.  I believe that Burke and Hare detached themselves from the act of killing and collecting the bodies.  Is it possible for killers to be complete numb and extricate themselves from their actions?  Do killers, or scientist like Dr. Knox, lack empathy?  All in all, I think Burke and Hare are not acting as autonomous individuals and can not be labeled as madmen.

Emelia Carter

posted by Dr. Renzi on her behalf